Leaving DBT

I’d heard such good things about DBT and the wide array of issues it can help with. But once I began the therapy things very quickly went downhill for me. My voices were so loud in the group, defiant they wouldn’t be silenced, that it was difficult to concentrate, and I had so many questions that didn’t feel welcome. I felt like I was expected to just absorb the information given and make it work.  The skills of Dialectical Behavioural Therapy seemed to contradict each other and some sounded like they were straight out of ‘The Little Book of Calm’.

One of the skills ‘Radical acceptance’ is about just accepting the past. I wondered why anyone is in therapy at all if radical acceptance is the ideal cure. Society constantly asks us to radically accept whatever has happened to us. But I don’t know anyone who has found the societal kicking to ‘just get on with it’ healing. I became more and more sceptical of some of the skills, no matter how open minded I tried to be. It made me realise that in order to be more mindful I needed to understand myself and get properly assessed. Until this happens I can’t put everything aside and ‘just be mindful’ as DBT asked me to.

Another of the barriers for me was that my mood does not tend to swing violently on a day to day basis. I could go weeks or months where I didn’t have a real life depression to practice skills with. I practiced anyway, several hours on each homework and two visits to the clinic every week. However when there was a real life situation where a skill could be used, I found that dissociation meant I couldn’t apply any techniques. I found it increasingly more and more humiliating going to one to one sessions and hearing about all the things I should have done, when at the time I wasn’t aware of being in my body; let alone the whereabouts of my DBT worksheets. My OCD and general perfectionism made me incredibly anxious about the whole process. I tried bloody hard, but I couldn’t be the perfect DBT student. This alone made me despise myself even more than I did already. My mind had set me up with that goal, but unfortunately that goal became a big part of my DBT process failing.

DBT works for a lot of people and this is only my opinion. But the more I went to DBT the more I felt like I was in a sitcom about therapy. Everything from the clinking of the chimes at the beginning and end of a mindfulness activity and even some of the skills would have made great comedy material. One of the more notably bizarre skills was half smile and willing hands in which you look slightly sinister and wait for serenity to come upon you. My uncertainty as to whether DBT was the correct path for me seemed to frustrate my 1:1 therapist greatly. She said that by trying to get me involved she had been utilising the ‘foot in door’ technique and now she would move on and use the ‘door in face’ technique by suggesting I move on. I said that sounded like mind games. She said: “that’s DBT”.

In the end I realised that the amount of hours I was putting into something that was rendering me totally miserable was stopping me from being able to do things that did actually make me feel better. Energy is a precious commodity and after about two months and many hours I couldn’t sacrifice anymore of it. I did meet some lovely people in the DBT group who I admire immensely and wish the best of luck in their therapy. In the meantime I am having more assessments to work out what to do next. No therapy works well for everyone, we are all individuals. I was absolutely terrified that me leaving the therapy would mean I would not be offered any help again. This luckily did not happen and everyone working with me respects my choice and my right to receive treatment.  The ‘Mouse Does DBT’ category will now become ‘Mouse Tries’, a series of blogs about different techniques that may help people with mental health problems.

A mouse with crossed arms and closed eyes with the words 'oh well' above it's head

2 thoughts on “Leaving DBT

  1. I can’t speak about DBT, but, to be fair to the (what sounds like) ‘mindfulness’ element, I don’t think these people are doing it right. Of course, I’m judging it by your description, but I reckon your bullshit detectors are pretty reliable. Maybe there are just different schools of mindfulness – I’m a huge fan of Charlotte Joko Beck and the “ordinary mind” school of Zen. I’m pretty sure she would say that the idea that you “have to” accept anything is a load of hogwash. The whole point is to not sit there beating yourself up because you don’t feels what you (supposedly) ought to feel, or think what you “ought” to think. Please note that I’m not recommending Ordinary Mind as a form of therapy for mental and emotional distress – though I do have a book on it, which I really ought to get around to reading at some point.

  2. I have re-branded DBT in my head as Diabolical Bullshit Therapy since it was forced on me in 2005. Then I was telling every “professional” who even mentioned that, or Mindfulness ever since. It is, to me, laughable that one American woman came up with this bunch of nonsense which is supposed to help millions of people she’s never met. Then for nursing staff who enforced the DBT on me & 8 other women sat at a table copying stuff written on a board into our folders to say “we treat the person, not the diagnosis” is such a load of crap… I can’t believe that people actually buy into it, but I’m thinking what a nice little money-spinner for Marsha Linehan. But what really annoys me is how DBT & Mindfulness gets compared, or tries to steal from Buddhism. I’m not religious & I feel everyone is unique & entitled to their own beliefs…but of all the religious beliefs & practices, I feel that Buddhism makes the most sense. Way to ruin it for me Marsha! I’m not hateful towards people, recently diagnosed ADHD which actually makes more sense for me than Borderline, but I’ve known a lot of women with Borderline who have had such low self-esteem, that they’ve allowed DBT-pushers to corrupt their minds & have been robbed completely of the ability to think for themselves! So in conclusion, I agree that DBT is bullshit, I just feel lucky that I was strong enough to stand up to the “professionals” & I’m in a much better (although never unrealistically perfect) state of mind…

Leave a Reply